Andrew Rannells is down to dive into more onscreen drama and suspense with Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively .

"Well, [director] Paul Feig is always coming up with something," Rannells, 46, exclusively told Us Weekly of a potential third installment in the A Simple Favor film series at the New York City special screening of his new movie, I Don't Understand You , on Monday, June 2. "He doesn't do sequels. He sort of broke his own rule to do this sequel."

As for whether he would return for a potential third movie? "100 percent," Rannells told Us , adding that he hopes it would take place somewhere "as beautiful as Italy."

Rannells returned as Darren, a friend of Kendrick's Stephanie, in Another Simple Favor, which premiered on Prime Video last month. Set five years after the

See Full Page