A joint statement from Canada, France, and Britain regarding the situation in Gaza and the West Bank has sparked significant disappointment among some observers. Critics argue that the statement effectively rewards Hamas for its actions on October 7, when the group was responsible for the deaths of 1,200 civilians and the kidnapping of 250 others.

The statement has drawn comparisons to past military actions by these Western nations, which bombed cities like Raqqa and Mosul to combat ISIS. Critics contend that the same powers now express humanitarian concerns to shield Hamas from accountability for its actions.

Supporters of Israel assert that Hamas initiated the current conflict and that Israel has the right to defend itself against terrorism. They question how Canadian authorities would respond if similar atrocities were committed against Canadian citizens.

Hamas has been accused of hijacking international aid, diverting essential supplies such as food, fuel, and medical resources to the black market. Estimates suggest that this diversion has generated up to half a billion dollars, effectively funding the recruitment and arming of more terrorists. Under the Fourth Geneva Convention, aid restrictions are deemed lawful when there is a risk of diversion to enemy combatants.

Despite these challenges, Israel has reportedly ensured that sufficient aid has reached Gaza, with 25,000 aid trucks entering the region during a recent 42-day ceasefire. A new mechanism has been established to ensure that aid is distributed to those in need rather than being seized by Hamas.

Currently, Hamas is holding 58 hostages under dire conditions, with reports of starvation, torture, and murder. Observers note that the conflict could cease if Hamas were to disarm and release the hostages.

Critics argue that Hamas has never recognized Israel's right to exist. After Israel's withdrawal from Gaza in 2005, Hamas is said to have focused on building terror tunnels and stockpiling rockets instead of establishing a state.

The ongoing conflict raises concerns about the potential for future violence. Each ceasefire, critics warn, allows Hamas to regroup and prepare for further attacks.

In Canada, rising threats against Jewish and Israeli individuals have prompted Israel’s Ministry of Diaspora Affairs to elevate its travel alert for the country to Level 2. This decision follows a series of attacks on Jewish institutions and an increase in hostile rhetoric. Israelis in Canada are advised to avoid public displays of their Jewish or Israeli identity.

Leaders are urged to consider how their public statements may influence the rise in antisemitic attacks. The recent murder of two young embassy staff in Washington, D.C., by Elias Rodriguez, who reportedly shouted, "I did it for Palestine, I did it for Gaza," has heightened these concerns.

Supporters of Israel emphasize the need for the government to demand the release of hostages and to work towards a peaceful future. They also call for increased efforts to protect the Jewish community in Canada.