‘Please Don’t Come Back’: Carrie Underwood’s Future as ‘American Idol’ Judge In Jeopardy After ‘Disappointing’ Season and Backlash Over Finale Episode, Fans Say She Lacks ‘Warmth’

Carrie Underwood‘s return to “American Idol” was supposed to be a triumphant full-circle moment for the country superstar.

Now calls for her exit from the show that made her a star are growing louder. Fans are demanding she step down from her role as judge following a rocky season that ended in backlash over her treatment of the show’s first Black male winner in more than two decades.

Adding to the pressure are rumors that the “Jesus, Take the Wheel” singer is unhappy with her judging salary.

The 42-year-old, who won American Idol in 2005, is reportedly having second thoughts about continuing on the show. Insiders say producers are also unsure about her future.

According to Star Magazine, someone close to production revealed that Underwood told show bosses she’s “not 100 percent sure”