Warning! The following contains spoilers for the Dexter: Resurrection episode "Cats and Mouse." Stream it with a Paramount+ subscription and read at your own risk!

Just when I think Dexter: Resurrection 's storyline can't get any more complex, the Paramount+ series threw a curveball in the latest episode. After writing in recent weeks that I feared the series was blazing through writing off its all-star cast by having Dex take out the serial killers in the club as quickly as possible, we're now given a twist that has me questioning just how much longer the Bay Harbor Butcher can keep hunting.

As Angel Batista and the New York detectives start to get on the trail of what may be a larger conspiracy, Dexter was caught off guard by a surprise he hadn't expected about one

See Full Page