Hillary Clinton's birthday tribute to her husband, Bill Clinton, isn't helping the rumors about the state of his health.

On August 19, Hillary took to Instagram to celebrate the former president's 79th birthday by posting a very old shot of them embracing at a public event. In the photo, both Bill and Hillary look happy, youthful, and in great health as they laugh at something happening out of range. She captioned the throwback photo, "Happy birthday, dear Bill." And while the photo is a great memory of a happy moment they shared together as a couple (though Bill and Hillary's marriage is kind of strange overall), the fact that she posted it months into Bill's tragic health decline isn't giving the public much confidence about his well-being.

In case you didn't know, Bill has been plague

See Full Page