There’s no denying, 2025 has been a very disappointing season for the Diamondbacks and their fans. Coming off an 89-win season, adding major signings like Corbin Burnes, and with the largest payroll in franchise history, expectations were high. But a poor May (a record of 11-17) and dreadful July (9-16) crushed expectations of challenging for a playoff spot. The team was instead sellers at the trade deadline, clearing the decks of three highly significant pieces in Merrill Kelly, Eugenio Suarez and Josh Naylor, and effectively putting a stake through the campaign. It’s been a long time since there was such a large, negative gap between hopes and reality. But who is responsible?

We asked you that question earlier in the week, giving five options to chose from, as the person or group who we

See Full Page