Hulu’s new reality dating series Are You My First? puts 21 eligible singles who identify as virgins on a sun-soaked beach to explore first love and, maybe, first-time intimacy. Hosted by Bachelor Nation alums Kaitlyn Bristowe and Colton Underwood, the show blends awkward charm with earnest conversations and has already sparked a flood of fan questions about renewals, relationships, and where to follow the cast.

On August 25, 2025, cohosts Bristowe and Underwood told Swooon they want a Season 2 and teased tweaks to the format. Underwood floated stricter truth checks from the start, while both hosts said the show should remain a supportive “safe place” for late bloomers. They also noted an influx of would-be applicants sliding into their DMs, which bodes well for more casting.

Meanwh

See Full Page