The switch from an off-guard island full of hotties to an inbox full of DMs must be the most disorienting experience for a Love Island USA cast member. Leading up to the reunion on August 25, all the couples who left the Villa together were seemingly going strong — until they weren’t. Two couples are already facing rumors of a breakup, thanks to the most incriminating detective work yet: their Instagram following list.

Amaya Espinal and Bryan Arenales Photo: Ben Symons/Peacock

Status at the reunion: Still together

Post-reunion status: Unfollowed

The internet has a lot to say about what Bryan was doing in the club once he got out of the villa, with several people accusing him of cheating . He said he had a “lapse” of judgment — the lapse being pouring shots and having a good

See Full Page