Some fans take shows with high Rotten Tomatoes scores for granted, but the reality is that only a handful ever score 90 percent or higher on RT.

That’s one of the reasons why only two of the new shows on Netflix in September reached that benchmark.

However, the third show came so close to hitting the mark that we’re going to give it a pass for this month. Besides, any positive critical appraisals before its Netflix debut may push it over 90 percent.

In the meantime, you can find Watch With Us‘ latest roundup of the new Netflix shows with at least 90 percent on Rotten Tomatoes below.

27 Must-Watch Shows on Netflix Right Now (September 2025): 'Nashville' and More

‘Orphan Black’ (2013 – 2017)

Rotten Tomatoes rank: 93 percent

Orphan Black made a star out of Tatiana Maslany by giving her

See Full Page