• Nick & Toni's is a true Hamptons establishment. • It's also a longtime favorite of the queen of the Hamptons, Ina Garten. • I paid a visit to Nick & Toni's to see for myself if it's worth the hype.

Generally speaking, you can't go wrong in life if you're taking advice from Ina Garten.

That's why, on a recent trip to the Hamptons, I decided to stop by one of Garten's favorite restaurants: Nick & Toni's.

While I had mentally prepared to spend upward of $50 on an entrée, when checking the menu, I found that there were plenty of things in the $30 to $40 range, which meant I didn't have to break the bank if I didn't want to. Of course, spending $47 on a piece of swordfish isn't a daily thing for me, but … when in Rome!

Here's what it was like to visit Nick & Toni's, where, sadly, I di

See Full Page