The New York Yankees have just been knocked out of the postseason after losing Game 4 of the ALDS against the Toronto Blue Jays. The whole Yankees offense seemed to struggle to get into a groove. Yet only Anthony Volpe is held accountable.

One such fan is a Super Bowl champion and Travis Kelce’s ex-teammate, Gehrig Dieter . After the game ended, Dieter posted, “If Volpe is the Yankees’ starting SS next year, I’m retiring from being a fan.” And looking at the performance Volpe has put up offensively, most would have the same feeling.

Anthony Volpe ’s 2025 regular season has been a challenge, both offensively and defensively. He played 153 games at shortstop, committing 19 errors, resulting in a .963 fielding percentage overall. Fans noticed his struggles, especially since the leag

See Full Page