When Frank Sinatra’s “New York, New York” plays at Yankee Stadium, it usually signals a Yankees win — not after Game 4 of the AL Division Series.

Moments after the Blue Jays’ 5-2 win on Wednesday , officially eliminating the Yankees from the postseason, the song played in the visitors’ clubhouse, where a champagne celebration was underway.

This was reminiscent of right-fielder Aaron Judge, who played the song prematurely in a boombox after beating the Red Sox in Game 2 of the AL Division Series in 2018. Only, this time, the Blue Jays played it when it counted — the Yankees famously lost that series in four games.

The trolling didn’t end there for the Blue Jays, who played this series like they had something to prove. To conclude his postgame interview on FS1, where Yankees legends D

See Full Page