After reaching the World Series last season, many expected the New York Yankees to do the same in 2025. Despite losing superstar outfielder Juan Soto, GM Brian Cashman quickly pivoted. The longtime Yankee general manager traded for outfielder Cody Bellinger and reliever Devin Williams in addition to signing lefty starter Max Fried in free agency. While these moves in addition to deals at the trade deadline helped New York return to the postseason, their season ended in the AL Division Series (ALDS). Now, Yanks fans are split on whether Cashman and manager Aaron Boone should return, according to the Athletic's Jordy Fee-Platt in a recent article.

“The Athletic’s readers were asked to share their thoughts on the matter with a poll asking fans to select from four options: fire both,

See Full Page