Let’s face it, dogs can be mischievous when they want to be. That guilty look they give when caught doing something questionable? It’s their secret weapon.

Most of the time, they flash those eyes and we cave, letting them get away with it again. It’s clever, and it works.

But one South Carolina family had no idea what their dog was about to pull off inside PetSmart. And it definitely wasn’t part of the plan.

A Sneaky Move No One Saw Coming

While visiting PetSmart in South Carolina, Teddy’s dad was taken by surprise when he noticed his dog had made an unexpected move.

Teddy had swiped a plush toy. A classic case of canine shoplifting. His dad was stunned and realized he’d have to go back and pay for it.

Teddy, meanwhile, turned on the charm, flashing his best puppy eyes and hoping

See Full Page