Emery Sharpnack scored her team-high 12th and 13th goals of the season, including the game-winner in double overtime as Pitman edged Clayton 3-2 in Pitman.
Bella Pramov scored the tying goal in the second half for the Panthers (8-5), who split the season series with the Clippers (9-4).
Both teams are now 6-2 in the Tri-County Conference Classic Division with two games to play each. Gloucester Catholic is also in the mix for the division title at 5-1.
Deondria Simon and Kennedy Eaddy scored for Clayton.