Love Is Blind season 9 star Kait Nemunaitis found herself in a pod love triangle — but left the show single.

Kait hit it off with costar Nick Amato in the pods, bonding over shared interests in camping and skiing.

“I think a lot of people were really off-put by him, but I just was like, ‘I feel like we’re clicking so much and we’re aligned on so many things,’” Kait recalled on an October 2025 episode of the “Love to See It” podcast. “It felt very natural for me and him initially. It’s wild because you only see the moments with me and Nick, but we’re also having other really strong, intense connections with other people.”

Nick was pursuing eventual fiancée Annie Lancaster at the same time, while Kait often spoke with Blake Anderson and Brendan Guthrie, respectively. (Annie also had a con

See Full Page