From chocolate classics to “grandma candies,” Americans are showing their sweet tooth in a big way this fall. DoorDash released new data breaking down which candies are most frequently ordered across the country — and some of the jumps are eye-popping.

Here’s what the numbers reveal:

#1: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups hold the crown

Reese’s remains the undisputed favorite candy in the U.S., keeping its top spot for another year. DoorDash says Americans continue to crave the iconic peanut butter and chocolate combo more than any other sweet.

+118% and +114%: Sour candies bring the bite back

Warheads and Lemonheads are back in demand, growing 114% and 118% respectively. DoorDash data shows sour treats are especially popular in Oklahoma, where SweeTarts top the state’s list.

+641%: Baby Bot

See Full Page