Season after season, several Dancing With the Stars contestants earn perfect 10s from judges — but there are only a few that take the cake for Us.

In Us Weekly’s latest cover story, the ballroom’s favorite brother-sister duo — current cohost Julianne Hough and judge Derek Hough — weighed in on their personal favorite routines through the years. Fellow judges Carrie Ann Inaba and Bruno Tonioli also revealed which numbers swept them off their feet — despite Tonioli’s initial hesitancy to point to a specific dance in particular.

“I think if you pick one [dance as a favorite], it’s almost like taking credit away from what everyone else has achieved,” Tonioli explained. “I don’t think I loved every season. I couldn’t say, ‘Oh God, I hated it.’ No. Because [there are] ups and downs of [the] bu

See Full Page