Witney Carson won season 19 of Dancing With the Stars over a decade ago, and it’s safe to say she’s ready for a second mirrorball.

The professional dancer nabbed her first champion title alongside current co-host Alfonso Ribeiro . One year later, Witney competed on season 21 as Bindi Irwin entered the ballroom and won the show again alongside judge Derek Hough. Supporting her throughout the journey was her younger brother Robert Irwin , who was a only 11 years old when his sister earned her mirrorball trophy.

Witney tells The Hollywood Reporter she “never in a million years” thought she’d be partnered up with the younger Irwin child when she first met him 10 years ago. “It never crossed my mind, but now that it’s happened, it feels right,” she explains.

Witney Carson won sea

See Full Page