Peacock's 'All Her Fault' Is the Second Best Streaming Mystery Series of 2025

Header Image Source: Peacock

Streaming mystery series are my catnip. I watch as many as I can in my ongoing search for greatness, even if that means suffering through dozens of baffling Harlan Coben series or mediocre scandi noirs . My favorite mystery series so far in 2025 is Netflix’s Dept Q . Formerly, my second favorite was Patience on PBS, followed by Better Sister on Prime Video. But both of those have moved down a notch after the release of Peacock’s All Her Fault .

The trailer did not look good , but I was wrong to dismiss it. I should have trusted the cast: Sarah Snook leads an impressive ensemble that includes Jake Lacy, Abby Elliott, Michael Peña, and Jay Ellis. It’s a missing

See Full Page