After nearly four years of litigation, the business divorce that wrecked a successful Denver roofing company has ended in a mixed verdict involving fraud and phony finances.

A Good Roofer, which is headquartered in Nebraska and had a Denver subsidiary until closing it in 2024, was owned by Ryan Scheeler and Tim Day through 2020. That year, they decided to sell it. Matt Hirschbiel, a Denverite and a friend of Scheeler, was interested in buying.

With revenue of $5.7 million in 2019 and a profit of $600,000, according to its tax filings, the company was thriving. A report on AGR’s finances that Scheeler had accountants prepare ahead of the sale to Hirschbiel painted an even prettier picture: about $6.6 million in revenue, $1.2 million in profit.

“I know I can get us a minimum of 3x (earnin

See Full Page