Hugh Jackman probably thought he was being a supportive boyfriend with his gushing Instagram post about Sutton Foster’s Tuesday night performance at Cafe Carlyle in New York City — but fans didn’t see it that way.

Instead of complimentary comments about their relationship, Jackman’s critics reminded him of his ex-wife, Deborra-Lee Furness. The post showed a smiling snapshot of Foster with her musicians, and a video clip of her waving to the camera. He wrote in the caption on November 26, “@suttonlenore performing during the holidays at @cafecarlyle … now that’s an iconic NYC night! And, truly magical.”

You can see the post here.

Well, the response was a little more biting than the 57-year-old actor probably expected. One follower wrote in the comments, “Reminiscent of the praise you alw

See Full Page