Yes, Damian Hardung and Harriet Herbig-Matten know that the detail-oriented fans of Maxton Hall are theorizing about the show. The stars of the Prime Video series , based on the books by Mona Kasten, tell Elite Daily some of their favorite reactions to the newly released second season, including the fan theory they think could be true.

“I love that they are complaining about the timeline and they're confused about it,” says Herbig-Matten, who plays Ruby Bell. Some of those discrepancies have fueled a lot of speculation among the fandom, giving birth to what Hardung calls his “favorite fan theory” of all.

“The one with Percy and the car crash,” Hardung says, singling out the unconfirmed guesses about his character James Beaufort’s real father .

For anyone who isn’t caught up on

See Full Page