NEW YORK CITY — Amid the ongoing Israel-Hamas conflict, a recent incident involving the only Catholic church in Gaza has drawn attention. The church, which has provided refuge for many, was damaged by Israeli fire last month. The attack resulted in the death of three individuals and injuries to the parish priest. This incident has raised concerns within the small Catholic community in Gaza, which has received special attention from Catholic leaders. The late Pope Francis would often call the pastor to check on the situation.

The Israel Defense Forces stated that the bombing was unintentional. In response, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu reached out to Pope Leo XIV to explain the circumstances surrounding the incident. Additionally, Israeli diplomats worldwide contacted local Catholic leaders to express their regrets and apologies for the misfire. However, the growing international skepticism regarding Israeli policies in Gaza has turned this accidental bombing into another point of contention.

In a positive development, the American Jewish Committee (AJC) in New York announced a donation of $25,000 to help repair the damaged Holy Family Church. The funds will be sent through the Archdiocese of New York. This gesture has been welcomed, as it reflects a sense of humanity that some believe the Israeli government has struggled to convey during the conflict.

Michael Oren, a former Israeli ambassador to the United States, recently criticized the current Israeli government's approach in a scathing essay on antisemitism. He noted that the late Hamas leader, Yahya Sinwar, exploited long-standing prejudices against Jews to benefit Hamas, even amid military losses. Oren stated, "In betting on Jew-hatred, Sinwar hit the jackpot," highlighting the rise of antisemitism globally, including in Canada.

Oren also pointed out the ongoing food crisis in Gaza, stating that Israel's inconsistent humanitarian aid policies have worsened the situation. He remarked, "Israel’s erratic policy of supplying, then denying, then again supplying humanitarian aid to Gaza... surely exacerbated the food shortage." He criticized the Israeli government's failure to effectively communicate and defend its policies, which he described as monumental.

The sentiments expressed by Oren resonate with a significant number of Israelis and many of Israel's traditional allies, who have increasingly questioned the Netanyahu government's policies. There is a growing consensus that these policies have damaged Israel's international standing.

Next year marks the 30th anniversary of Netanyahu's first election as prime minister. He has consistently opposed the establishment of a Palestinian state and the Oslo Accords of 1993. Two decades ago, he resigned as finance minister in protest of the Gaza withdrawal policy implemented by then-Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.

Despite achieving strategic victories, Netanyahu now faces a rapid decline in support from allies. Recently, he announced plans for Israel to retake full control of Gaza, a move that raises concerns about the potential cost in lives for both Israelis and Palestinians. This decision comes two decades after Sharon's withdrawal from Gaza, which was based on the belief that continued Israeli presence was unjustifiable.

Netanyahu's current approach, which includes a more intense military strategy, has drawn criticism from both military leaders and the public. His government has been accused of fostering a climate of violence and displacement, with some officials openly expressing desires to drive Palestinians out of Gaza. As the conflict continues, the international community watches closely, with many opposing Netanyahu's current strategies.