To kick off the 2025 MLB season, we brought together more than 60 ESPN baseball experts to rank the 100 best players in the sport .

More than four months later, some things have stayed more or less the same ... and some things have changed quite a bit. In that spirit, we decided to rerank the top 50, based on what we've seen so far this season -- and what we expect to see down the stretch.

So ... how did we do? We asked some of the voters who participated in both rankings to critique the new list and reevaluate the original one.

Digging into the in-season update list

Who's ranked too high on our updated list?

Olney: It's a little bonkers that we have Nick Kurtz above Freddie Freeman , who less than a year ago dominated baseball's biggest event, or Pete Alonso , who just tied

See Full Page