Sarah Pidgeon and Paul Kelly are spending another night on set.

The 26-year-old actress and the 28-year-old actor got into character as Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy and John F. Kennedy Jr. as they filmed scenes for American Love Story outside of an apartment building on Monday night (August 18) in New York City.

For their time on set, Sarah wore a black coat over a black dress while Paul sported a black suit and white button-down shirt.

American Love Story , which premieres in February 2026, will follow JFK Jr. and Carolyn ‘s whirlwind romance. The couple passed away in a plane crash in 1999 when she was 33 and he was 38. They were the subject of lots of media scrutiny when their romance began, through their deaths.

In a new interview, RHONY alum Carole Radziwi

See Full Page