The central question driving The Summer I Turned Pretty isn’t just about summer flings or beach houses—it’s about Belly’s heart. Fans continue to debate: Who truly loves Belly more—Conrad or Jeremiah? Both brothers bring something different to the table, and the series has carefully crafted arguments for (and against) each of them. Let’s break it down.

Why Conrad Might Love Belly More

Depth of Emotion: Conrad’s love often runs deep, even if it isn’t always verbalized. His quiet intensity shows that his feelings for Belly are profound, not fleeting.

History Together: Belly has adored Conrad for years, and their shared memories provide a long-standing foundation for their relationship that Jeremiah can’t fully replicate.

Sacrifice: Conrad repeatedly steps back when he believes i

See Full Page