The Giants.com crew members react to the initial 53-man roster.

John Schmeelk: I've been at this game of trying to predict the initial 53-man roster for more than a decade. No one ever gets all 53 correct. The amount of institutional knowledge about these players inside the building between the front office and coaches dwarfs whatever anyone not involved in those continuous offseason discussions knows. Whenever I try to come up with my list, I try to take 25 offensive players, 25 defensive players and then the three specialists. Usually, the final numbers wind up somewhere in that window, though this year was a bit of an exception.

The Giants kept 26 offensive players with only 24 coming on defense, but there should be a few notes. Though Gunner Olszewski is technically an offensive pla

See Full Page