A man in Lindsay, Ontario, faces multiple charges after allegedly breaking into a home while armed with a crossbow. The incident occurred early on August 18, and the suspect, Michael Kyle Breen, was reportedly on probation at the time. Court documents filed on Wednesday detail the violent confrontation that ensued between Breen and the homeowner, Jeremy David McDonald.

Breen, 41, is charged with four offenses, including break-and-enter and carrying a weapon for the purpose of committing an offense. According to police, he broke a window and screen at McDonald’s residence, which is located in the Kawartha Lakes area. Following the break-in, a physical altercation took place, resulting in Breen sustaining severe injuries that required airlifting to a Toronto hospital.

McDonald, 44, has been charged with aggravated assault and assault with a weapon, reportedly a knife. Both men were known to each other prior to the incident, with Breen’s residence listed as being less than 600 meters from McDonald’s apartment. However, local police and McDonald’s attorney have not confirmed any specific connection between the two.

The case has sparked a nationwide discussion in Canada regarding the legalities of self-defense. Premier Doug Ford commented on the situation, suggesting that the charges against McDonald indicate a flaw in the legal system. "I know if someone breaks into my house or someone else's, you're going to fight for your life," Ford stated. He also criticized the judicial system for allowing repeat offenders like Breen to remain free on bail.

Legal experts have weighed in on the matter, clarifying that while self-defense is permissible in Canada, it must be deemed reasonable. Criminal lawyer Tonya Kent explained that the force used in self-defense must be proportional to the threat faced. "If someone assaults another person by pushing them, that person can't then pick up a baseball bat and start beating them and claim self-defense. That's not reasonable force," she said.

The Lindsay Police Association emphasized that thorough investigations are conducted before any charges are laid, ensuring they align with the evidence and the Criminal Code of Canada. Breen made his first court appearance on Wednesday, while McDonald is scheduled to appear in court on September 25. McDonald’s attorney has stated that his client maintains his innocence and believes he acted within his rights to defend himself and his property.