If there’s any lesson to be had from the movie Caught Stealing , it’s to never say “yes” to pet-sitting for your neighbor unless you really trust them. Set in 1998 New York, Hank (played by Austin Butler ) gets dragged into a mess after agreeing to watch his neighbor’s cat while he returns to London. While Hank’s city skills get tested as he’s thrown into the criminal underworld between cops, mobsters (including a red-haired Bad Bunny ), and the Orthodox Jewish community, through it all, he leans on his kind-of girlfriend, Yvonne ( Zoë Kravitz ), an EMT and real New Yorker, until he can’t anymore.

While the plot is entertaining and fast-paced, the best part of the film is how it serves as a love letter to the East Village in the ’90s. And with that, the costumes created by Amy W

See Full Page