Alberta Premier Danielle Smith's government is facing criticism for its recent policies regarding school library book bans and the participation of transgender girls in sports. These measures have been described by some as a form of virtue signaling, reminiscent of tactics used by former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.

The United Conservative Party (UCP) has implemented a ban on certain books in school libraries, claiming it addresses concerns about explicit content. Critics argue that this ban is politically motivated and inflates the issue beyond its actual scope. The UCP's approach has led to heightened emotions and divisions within the community.

Additionally, a new law requires school boards to verify the sex assigned at birth for students suspected of being transgender before allowing them to participate in sports. This requirement has raised alarms among advocates who view it as an invasion of privacy. They argue that such laws can have harmful consequences and create a culture of distrust among students and families.

The UCP's actions have forced school districts to navigate these controversial laws while also preparing for potential teacher strikes or lockouts. Critics contend that the focus should be on addressing the needs of transgender students in a compassionate manner rather than engaging in political posturing.

The book ban has also drawn attention, particularly after the government extended its reach to include non-explicit sexual content. This led to a backlash when classic literature was inadvertently included in the list of banned materials, prompting an international uproar. In response, the government has since backtracked, but not before Smith accused school boards of “vicious compliance.”

On another front, the government recently planned a briefing on updated standards for school library materials, but the announcement was abruptly delayed, raising questions about the decision-making process within the education department. This incident has left many wondering about the government's priorities amid ongoing economic challenges.

Alberta's unemployment rate currently stands at 8.4%, the second highest in Canada, with a significant drop in available jobs reported in August. As the government focuses on these contentious social issues, critics argue that it is diverting attention from pressing economic concerns affecting many Albertans, particularly the youth.