Four games into the 2025 NFL season, the rookie class has already sorted into tiers , and the Offensive Rookie of the Year race has taken early shape. At this point, voters prize two things above all else: consistent opportunity and production in high-leverage moments. That means red-zone looks, third-down conversions, and splash plays that swing games.

So let's take a look at the five rookies who have earned meaningful roles, produced impact plays, and built statistical resumes that can survive scrutiny over the long haul. Each name on this list examines why the player matters now, what could derail the bid, and what they must sustain to stay in the conversation.

Who takes the top spot? Let's count down the top five.

5. Panthers WR Tetairoa McMillan

McMillan was drafted eighth over

See Full Page