As we now look back on the 2025 Yankees’ season, it’s hard to still not have a sense of frustration. As a team, they came up short of their World Series championship goal once again, going down fairly meekly to the Blue Jays in the ALDS.

However as we continue our season in review, today we’re going to look back at some individual greatness. You can’t really argue that there were several Yankees who had really good seasons just on an individual level. With that in mind, today we’re going to award our 2025 Yankee Most Valuable Player and Yankee Cy Young Award. Spoiler alert: you’re not going to be surprised by the choices.

Most Valuable Player

Considering that he’s going to be at worst a close second for the American League MVP, you can’t give this honor to anyone but Aaron Judge.

The Y

See Full Page