[Warning: The following post contains MAJOR spoilers for Murder in a Small Town Season 2 Episode 5, “Strangers Among Us.”]

The newest case in Murder in a Small Town wasn’t precisely a murder. Rather, it was an accidental death that resulted in a years-long stalking, a self-defense shooting, and an attempted murder.

Tyler Posey was a featured guest star of the episode, starring as Ryan Coogan, a man who came forward to talk to Karl Alberg ( Rossif Sutherland ) after his friend Jack was found shot and bleeding out on the side of the road. He appeared exceedingly helpful and sincere and even showed up at the hospital in hopes of giving his friend, whom he’d met years before at grief counseling, some of his healing crystals.

All was not what it seemed beneath the surface, of course. As

See Full Page