STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — Randall Manor Tavern in West Brighton will serve its final meal at its longtime 735 Castleton Avenue location this Sunday, Oct. 26 2025 before shutting its doors to prepare for a move.

The popular neighborhood bar and restaurant isn’t going away for long. Plans call for reopening at a new, expanded location on November 4 at 382 Forest Avenue, where patrons can expect chef Steve Rowan’s signature comfort food alongside new additions. Co-owner Steve Noss said his business partner, John Venturella, will also be in the kitchen, preparing pizzas and fresh house-made pastas.

“He’s shifting from just being the bartender to playing a key role in producing the daily specials and tweaked menu,” Noss said.

Carrie Gaeta, a longtime bartender at Randall Manor Tavern since its i

See Full Page