Peggy Noonan and the Dangers of Uncritical Thinking

Elvis Presley, as most would agree, sang beautiful songs. But he was wise enough not to attempt composing any of them. Peggy Noonan has written beautiful words and phrases, but she should have the wisdom to collaborate with a sound thinker whose thoughts, not hers, might be expressed through her belles-lettres. In her attempts to appear thoughtful, writing rhythmically from an Olympian perch, she dispenses vapidity disguised as wisdom. Her recent column, "A Republic, But Can We Keep It?" unwittingly shows the danger of a lack of critical thinking to our republic, not, as she claims to...