Emotional criminal trial likely after Toms River, NJ crash that killed young couple Rick Rickman Published: November 6, 2025 Three young men charged with killing Kiley Armstrong and Evan Fiore have rejected plea deals, and the case is likely heading to trial (Ocean County Jail/GoFundMe via Cole Crozier)

🔴 Three men accused in a deadly 120 mph crash face decades in prison.

🔴 Prosecutors say the suspects egged each other on to “floor it”

🔴 Victims Kiley Armstrong and Evan Fiore were planning to marry.

TOMS RIVER — Three young men have not accepted plea deals that would put them in state prison for a combined 70 years, according to prosecutors.

It means that the families of Kiley Armstrong, 21, and Evan Fiore, 23, could have to endure a criminal trial before their accused kill

See Full Page