After their first date, Colin Jost thought Scarlett Johansson just wasn’t that into him.

But the Black Widow actress admitted that she didn’t let her true feelings show during her first meet up with the Saturday Night Live comedian, noting she was completely out of her element.

“Nobody had ever asked me out before,” Scarlett reflected during the Dec. 1 episode of Today . “I was a serial monogamist and I never got the sort of traditional like, ‘Hey would you like to have dinner sometime?’”

But when the Pop Culture Jeopardy! host took a shot, Scarlett—who shares daughter Rose , 11, with ex Romain Dauriac as well as son Cosmo , 4, with Colin—made it seem like it was a total airball.

“He actually asked me out on a date,” Scarlett recalled. “We we

See Full Page