An interesting set of discussions in the nominations thread. Some candidates I had completely forgotten about, and others worthy of consideration. However, after tossing and turning all night, I have decided not to include Eugenio Suarez’s fourth home-run on the ballot: I strongly suspect that’s going to get its moment in the sun later this month! As noted, what made that special was largely what had gone before. Though by that logic, you could argue that Ketel Marte’s home-run was only special for the same. Oh, well. I also had to disqualify ‘Hacks well-rec’d nomination of Corbin Carroll’s throw home. Something to do with it having taken place in 2024… 🙂

Oddly, nobody nominated any of the infield plays, so I’m wielding my executive power and picking one of those to round out the ballot

See Full Page