It was a narrow win for Sandie Peggie in the employment tribunal against NHS Fife . But an depth reading of the judgment is favourable for transgender medic Dr Beth Upton .

The Herald has read all 312 pages of the employment tribunal's decision, with the Kirkcaldy nurse winning over her employment on harassment grounds.

But on discrimination and victimisation on the basis of her gender critical beliefs, all other claims were dismissed. It is too early to say whether her legal team will appeal.

Sex Matters, a key supporter of Ms Peggie through the tribunal, has already expressed disappointed at multiple aspects on the case.

Here are the biggest takeaways from the judgment.

Protected characteristics

In Ms Peggie's legal case, it was claimed that permitting transgender medic Dr

See Full Page