Joe Maire scored the game-winning goal in overtime to cap a crazy 6-5 victory over Old Tappan.

Colten Lathrop scored two of his three goals in the first period to put Old Tappan (2-1) on top early.

Pascack Valley (2-1) scored four goals in the second period to take control. Jack Sheehan scored two goals and added an assist while Owen Dargan finished with one goal and three assists.

Lathrop and Alexandra Labe scored third-period goals to put Old Tappan up, 5-4.

Maire found the back of the net in the third to send the game to overtime before winning it for Pascack Valley.

More N.J. High School Sports stories

Howell tops St. John Vianney - Boys ice hockey recap Dec. 10, 2025, 11:54p.m.

West Essex-Caldwell defeats Summit - Boys ice hockey recap Dec. 10, 2025, 11:38p.m.

See Full Page