Are You My First? sparked several romantic connections between the virgin contestants — but which couples are still dating and who has broken up?

Hosted by Colton Underwood and Kaitlyn Bristowe, Are You My First?, which premiered in August 2025, introduced a new dating experiment where virgins navigated love, lust and losing it. Viewers saw a group of hopeful contestants exploring connections, pairing up and even eliminating each other in what the show referred to as “virgin sacrifices.”

The season 1 finale ended in two couples solidifying their romance — but no swiping of V-cards.

“We really pushed them out of their comfort zones,” Kaitlyn said on the show before Colton joked, “We have done everything except guide it in at this point.”

Which 'Are You My First?' Stars Remained Virgins

See Full Page