L.A. Hubilla is a contributing shopping writer for PEOPLE who specializes in fashion, beauty, and lifestyle topics. As a former professional dancer, she knows a thing or two about tights. In tandem with former PEOPLE shopping writer Alyssa Brascia , she reviewed testing data to help compile this list.

The quest for the perfect black tights can be an overwhelming one. Whether you’re looking for shapewear-inspired tights or a pair of fleece-lined ones that’ll keep you cozy during the cold weather months, black tights are a must-have for your wardrobe. “I love how tights can elevate a look from basic to chic while adding warmth,” says NYC-based personal stylist Adrian Causing . “They also extend your wardrobe, transitioning pieces from spring to fall, and fall to winter.”

We te

See Full Page