Cook

Baking

Step Aside, Libby's — This Superstore Makes The Best Canned Pumpkin By Jonathan Kesh Sept. 28, 2025 7:00 am EST

With autumn fast approaching, we're entering pumpkin pie season, and there are lots of canned pumpkin brands competing for shelf space in your kitchen. We here at The Takeout put together an ultimate ranking of canned pumpkin brands , with the goal of finding the best pumpkin purée out there, short of mashing up a fresh pumpkin yourself. The odds were in favor of Libby's, which has long been a famous name in pumpkin pie filling. How did it actually compare to other brands, though? Surprisingly, an underdog took the top pumpkin purée prize, and our taste test winner was Good & Gather, one of the store brands at Target.

Good & Gather offers both regular

See Full Page