Grocery

Shopping

We Ranked This Store-Bought Ice Cream Sandwich Best Without Contest By Javaria Akbar Oct. 5, 2025 5:39 pm EST

Jenn Carnevale / Static Media

There's something about the sensory experience of eating an ice cream sandwich that makes it taste better than a soft serve cone. It must be all that cookie goodness on your fingers and the sound of the melty ice cream squishing between the wafers. In our eyes, an epic cream sandwich has to have two key features: A yummy velvety filling and a solid exterior that won't disintegrate into pieces when the ice cream starts to melt. Taking all this into account, the best store-bought ice cream sandwich without contest is made by Klondike.

The winner in our ranking of 13 store-bought ice cream sandwiches , Klondike's offering

See Full Page