Why You Should Avoid Whole Foods' Plain Yogurt

Cook

Ingredients

Why You Should Avoid Whole Foods' Plain Yogurt By Dennis Lee Oct. 19, 2025 10:00 am EST

Plain yogurt sounds boring, but the lot we tried during our plain yogurt ranking of seven store-bought brands yielded some really interesting results. We learned that some plain yogurts can taste like the feed the cattle were raised on (such as grass), while others are nearly sweet due to their creaminess. But the one plain yogurt that disappointed us most comes from Whole Foods' house brand, 365, which is known for consistently delivering poor taste in its generic line of products .

Our taste tester found that while it's not the worst yogurt in the world, per se, it's simply disappointing. They wrote, "The texture is gelatinous, on the thicker and stickier side t