What happens when a former UFC champion casually weighs in on one of MMA’s most sacred “What if?” debates? You get chaos, confusion, and a fanbase ready to storm the comment section with pitchforks. That’s exactly what unfolded after Robert Whittaker’s recent appearance on his MMArcade Podcast, where he tackled the unthinkable: Prime Georges St-Pierre vs. Islam Makhachev . A question so loaded it might as well have come wrapped in caution tape.

The clip of the discussion was shared on X by RedCornerMMA, and it started innocently enough. His co-host asked , “Prime GSP versus Islam Makhachev, who wins? What do you reckon Rob?” Whittaker paused, breathed it in, and muttered the words every MMA fan recognises as the calm before the storm, “ Oh man, that’s tricky.”

Whittaker broke do

See Full Page