If you're ho-ho-hoping for festive coffee flavors this holiday season, Keurig has them in spades. The world's most popular single-serve coffee maker has inspired dozens of companies to unleash a wide variety of seasonal specials, from spiced Christmas blends and cooling peppermint mochas to tried-and-true pumpkin spice lattes and indulgent sugar cookie espressos.

But not all K-Cups are on Santa's Nice List this year. I put my palate (and my stomach) through the wringer by sipping through a whopping 32 flavor offerings to identify the best of the best (the Nice List), the just OK (Middle of the Pack) and the ones to skip (the Naughty List).

I brewed all the holiday coffee pods to find these 10 bangers. Joey Skladany/CNET

While taste is subjective, I kept brewing methods and prepa

See Full Page