A Colorado couple lived alongside the rotting corpse of their three-way lover for more than a year and spent his Social Security checks — as their tiny dogs sometimes “chewed” his body, according to cops.

James Agnew, 55, and Suzanne Agnew, 57, of Lakeland, allegedly hid the remains of longtime ménage à trois partner James O’Neill, 64, under an air mattress at their condo in Lakeland after he died in December 2023, police said in a jaw-dropping arrest affidavit.

Cops unearthed the twisted love triangle — and O’Neill’s decomposed corpse — during a welfare check on July 3, when O’Neill’s brother sent them to the home to look for him, Lakewood Police said. 3

After the gruesome discovery, Suzanne allegedly told cops she didn’t remove O’Neill’s body or call authorities after he died be

See Full Page