Edmonton Public Schools is considering the removal of around 200 books from its libraries due to new provincial guidelines regarding sexual content. The draft list of titles, which was recently leaked, includes works that contain graphic depictions of sex. The guidelines state that books with explicit sexual content should not be available in school libraries, while access to non-graphic depictions of sex should be limited to students in Grade 10 and above.

Among the titles facing removal is Jean M. Auel’s novel, which features a disturbing scene involving a 10-year-old protagonist who is beaten and raped by a Neanderthal. This book, along with others like George R.R. Martin’s series, which includes vivid sexual scenes and instances of rape, is under scrutiny. Diana Gabaldon’s time-traveling romance series, known for its graphic depictions of sexual violence, is also included in the list.

The list encompasses a range of genres, including award-winning literature and classics. Notable mentions include Vladimir Nabokov’s "Lolita," which addresses the sexual abuse of a young girl, and Margaret Atwood’s "The Handmaid’s Tale," which explores themes of sexual slavery. Maya Angelou’s autobiography, detailing her own rape at age eight, is also part of the proposed removals.

While some argue that these works should remain accessible to adults, the school board emphasizes the need to respect parental beliefs regarding what is appropriate for children. Laura Winton, former president of the Library Association of Alberta, stated that sexually explicit content does not inherently make a book unsuitable for children. However, she acknowledged that it is ultimately up to parents to decide what their children should read.

The school board's approach contrasts with actions taken in other provinces, where some school boards have removed books for reasons related to diversity and inclusion without transparency. In Edmonton, the process appears to be more open, allowing for community input on the matter.

The list also includes titles with sexual themes deemed suitable for older students, such as works by Atwood and others that contain less explicit content. The ongoing discussion highlights the complexities of balancing educational material with community standards and parental expectations.